Humber Bay for All

titlegraphic.PNG
On November 25 the West End Beaches Stakeholders Association (WEBSA) presented their Concept Plan for refurbishment of the breakwater and environment of Humber Bay, from Ontario Place to the Humber River. The presentation was given at the Argonaut Rowing Club. WEBSA, an independent, non-profit coalition, includes the Argonaut Rowing Club, The Boulevard Club, Sunnyside Paddling Club, and Toronto Sailing & Canoe Club, and aims at community engagement as a means to achieving positive changes to the waterfront of Toronto's western beaches.

image2.jpg

 

The WEBSA Concept Plan aims to address:

  • Impacts of high water levels, flooding, shoreline erosion, property damage
  • Breakwater disrepair and replacement
  • Impact on water and land recreation programmes
  • Martin Goodman Trail extensions
  • Increased recreation opportunities - land and water
  • Integration with Ontario Place
  • Humber River deflector arm and beach improvement
  • Provision for small craft availability and docking
To summarize, the current western beaches are shielded by a 105 year old breakwater that has reached the end of its useful life. WEBSA's proposal would see that old breakwall removed and a new one constructed, extending eastwards from the east end of the current dragon boat course breakwall to Ontario Place, and north and west from the west end of the current dragon boat course breakwall to the mouth of the Humber River. Diagrams of the proposal are available at https://www.humberbayforall.com/. Material from the old breakwall would be reused in constructing the new landmasses proposed
At the mouth of the Humber, a deflector arm is proposed to direct Humber River outflow further into Humber Bay to alleviate silting of the beaches. ​(This feature has been proposed by TRCA and Toronto Water for years. WEBSA has incorporated this feature, but it has been somewhat controversial.)   Additional landfill at the base of the deflector arm, just east of the Humber outfall would house recreational facilities.  ​
 
The section of breakwall from the Humber to about Sunnyside would be re-purposed to support a string of four islands, two of which would be connected to the shore and deflector arm with a series of pedestrian bridges integrated with the Martin Goodman Trail. ​ The other two islands would be inaccessible by foot and remain "Habitat Islands".​
The Concept Plan presented by WEBSA was developed with guidance by Walter Kehm, a landscape architect well regarded for his designs of the Tommy Thompson Park, and the recent Trillium Park at the east end of Ontario Place.
At this point WEBSA's goals are to build community and political support for their Concept Plan, and to refine its design further. To these ends the Open House they ran on November 25th presented their design and enabled a question and answer session. Feedback sheets were also provided on which visitors were invited to add their suggestions and comments.
WEBSA deserves credit for presenting a clear vision of how they would like to see the Humber Bay beaches and waterfront develop, and for opening their initiative to community input. They recognise that the next step in their progress depends on political support, and clearly see the importance of developing a community-focused design that has broad community participation in support of this goal.

 

Material from the old breakwall would be reused in constructing the new landmasses proposed (below).
At the mouth of the Humber, a deflector arm is proposed to direct Humber River outflow further into Humber Bay to alleviate silting of the beaches. 
​(This feature has been proposed by TRCA and Toronto Water for years. WEBSA has incorporated this feature, but it has been somewhat controversial.)  
 
Additional landfill at the base of the deflector arm, just east of the Humber outfall would house recreational facilities.  ​
 
The section of breakwall from the Humber to about Sunnyside would be re-purposed to support a string of four islands, two of which would be connected to the shore and deflector arm with a series of pedestrian bridges integrated with the Martin Goodman Trail. 
​ The other two islands would be inaccessible by foot and remain "Habitat Islands".

Latest posts

Harbourfront Rink Reborn

Many people were upset when Harbourfront's beloved skating rink by the lake was unexpectedly dismantled and taken away in 2023 due to lack of funds. Waterfront for All and two neighbourhood residents' associations objected.

The rink was a big wintertime draw for the waterfront. Its sudden removal seemed symptomatic of a general decline of Harbourfront Centre.

Thanks to Councillor's Ausma Malik's successful motion in City Council on October 10, 2024, there will be a seasonal rink set up this winter at Harbourfront.

There's also a vibrant new CEO at Harbourfront, Cathy Loblaw, and we welcome her!

City Council agrees to RESA 1

City Council voted on October 9, 2024, to accept RESA 1, the "minimal landmass" option presented by Ports Toronto. Ports Toronto had hoped to get City approval of other options, RESA 2 or 3, both major expansions of the airport involving as much as three times as much landfill. The federal government requires run-off areas at the end of runways known as Runway End Safety Areas (RESAs), which in the case of the island airport must be built by July 14, 2027.

Ports Toronto also hoped to get City Council to agree on October 9 to an extension of the Tripartite Agreement, the lease and operating agreement at the airport, for 40 years beyond its present expiry in 2033, that is, until 2073. Council allowed a limited extension for as much as 12 years, but only if Ports Toronto satisfies the City it can't afford to build RESA 1 (cost: around $65 million) without the extension. But City Staff have already concluded it has the money, and we agree. 

Next step: will Ports Toronto defy the City, and insist on airport expansion now? They may. We’ll find out at Ports Toronto’s meeting at 2 pm or 6 pm, Tuesday, October 15, 2024. Come and have your say!

City Council RESA vote coming

City Council will vote at its meeting October 9 - 11, 2024 whether to adopt the recommendations in the September 27 Staff Report .

It should do so! Here's our brief communication to Councillors as to why.

We believe and hope most Councillors will vote tomorrow to follow the Staff recommendations, adopted by Executive Committee, the Mayor and Councillor Ausma Malik: authorize the smallest, least intrusive option for Runway End Safety Areas, known as RESA 1, so as to deal with the pressing federal safety requirements now (RESAs must be built by July 14, 2027). As a separate matter, recommends Staff, take the time to study the bigger issues, such as whether the Tripartite Agreement, the airport land lease and operation agreement, should be extended in some form past its 2033 expiry, whether the airport should be expanded, including studies and public consultation exploring its adverse impacts and upsides, including we hope consideration and study of potential alternative uses of the land. 

It would be a crazy leap for Councillors to do what Ports Toronto and Nieuport want: reject city staff‘s recommendations, meaning: extend the tripartite agreement for 40 years NOW, and authorize the airport to build the other, bigger RESA options - allowing a huge non-safety-related airport expansion immediately. Ports Toronto and Nieuport demand Council vote to agree to all this NOW without any study of the local impacts, ecological and health issues, transportation efficiency, economic effects or consequences on future development in the Portlands and elsewhere.

We are deeply concerned that airport industry lobbyists have been misrepresenting the position of community representatives.

Contrary to the findings in the Staff Report, Ports Toronto claims it needs an extension of the Tripartite Agreement because it otherwise can't afford to build RESA 1. That's not true.

Share this post

Sign up for updates

Email: